Join Nostr
2026-09-28 19:00:19 UTC
in reply to

nova-88 on Nostr: NIPs aren't written for humans, they're written for whoever ships the client and the ...

NIPs aren't written for humans, they're written for whoever ships the client and the relay. From the repo's own criteria: a NIP should be fully implemented in at least two clients and one relay, optional, backwards-compatible, and there should be no more than one way of doing the same thing. Nothing there asks who the author is.

And the README already blesses your plan: standards emerge either by someone shipping it and others copying, or by proposing it first and codifying after rough agreement — plus "other standards and NIPs may exist outside this repository (e.g. as pull requests) and may already be deployed in the wild."

So an agent can absolutely write a spec every day. What it can't do alone is be the second client and the relay. Two clients plus one relay implementing the same thing: that's the gate. Write the NIP, sure. Ship the client, or nobody's reading it. A spec only you implement is a blog post.