isn’t this missing a crucial detail? The whole reason why those 100k users can be ...

2024-11-04 09:48:48 UTC

isn’t this missing a crucial detail?

The whole reason why those 100k users can be switched across service providers so easily is because all of their ID keys (did:plc) are stored on the singular Bluesky-operated https://plc.directory

That key-ownership does not change with the move, so complete Bluesky-independence has not happened yet in this case. Those users are still dependent on an essential piece of Bluesky-infrastructure.

Author Public Key

npub1hfwe7ujg3hj3zwt5v9jj8g02pxg67kqfdxsnx955ykl6ev024thqvd4jg3

Seen on

wss://relay.momostr.pink

Show more details

Published at

2024-11-04 09:48:48 UTC

Kind type

1 Short Text Note

Event JSON

{ "id": "3f380238aad4cd13671180cba92369dcefadadf277d86cd654162fa5a79242a8", "pubkey": "ba5d9f72488de5113974616523a1ea0991af580969a133169425bfacb1eaaaee", "created_at": 1730713728, "kind": 1, "tags": [ [ "content-warning", "Long thread/22" ], [ "p", "ee889600b02c05c130aab1eafadb77f2e37645810c058b505f3a0e9d7a95bdaa" ], [ "p", "ac8f4148747af03a8e9834d99bb81ad94ee75a54cce0c113971bb91b2a667eb4" ], [ "e", "56e56baa0f6318da4dfb6e7f927274a87a043bcc33c3873c19b12b505800d25b", "", "root", "4b461234559a9a14049435e1dd0e483916844ceadadfd6b5da824b157953bde6" ], [ "e", "a423da6e7ee292d5ce9dc3875fee4f2fb7b780c67b5da634fc4fd2c78964466f", "", "reply", "ee889600b02c05c130aab1eafadb77f2e37645810c058b505f3a0e9d7a95bdaa" ], [ "p", "06a84154eb68de2e78fd97b66dbddaa2f42d8f50fbc7d11119fc6bf964ecc870" ], [ "proxy", "https://writing.exchange/@erlend/113424054907497596", "web" ], [ "p", "4b461234559a9a14049435e1dd0e483916844ceadadfd6b5da824b157953bde6" ], [ "proxy", "https://writing.exchange/users/erlend/statuses/113424054907497596", "activitypub" ], [ "L", "pink.momostr" ], [ "l", "pink.momostr.activitypub:https://writing.exchange/users/erlend/statuses/113424054907497596", "pink.momostr" ], [ "-" ] ], "content": "isn’t this missing a crucial detail?\n\nThe whole reason why those 100k users can be switched across service providers so easily is because all of their ID keys (did:plc) are stored on the singular Bluesky-operated https://plc.directory\n\nThat key-ownership does not change with the move, so complete Bluesky-independence has not happened yet in this case. Those users are still dependent on an essential piece of Bluesky-infrastructure.", "sig": "a8559da82813f181ce9fc9c33be895258b8a52c295dea8f75f9674ac2f185588a90f39448600611f49968fec7372d733f21950674ee4e1c05669a125736ca05b" }

Erlend Sogge Heggen on Nostr: isn’t this missing a crucial detail? The whole reason why those 100k users can be ...