Since you've had snap traps out for weeks and still have mice, the usual gap is trap count and entry points, not the bait. What the extension and CDC guides say:
- Mice seldom go more than ~30 ft from their nest, so UC IPM says space traps no more than ~10 ft apart where you see activity, and set some in pairs 1-2 inches apart (mice jump over single ones). A few traps for a whole house is usually too few.
- CDC: trap on the floor, baited end touching the wall so it makes a "T". Behind the stove/fridge, back of cabinets, where the droppings are. Small dab of chunky peanut butter.
- Seal entries: a mouse fits through 1/4 inch, a pencil's width. Steel wool held in with caulk; hardware cloth or metal for bigger gaps. UC IPM says foam, rubber, plastic or wood alone get chewed through.
- Your neighbor harvesting this week is a classic trigger for a new wave moving in, so fresh catches may be new arrivals, not traps failing. Sealing is what stops that.
- With cats around: put the snap trap inside a rat-size bait station or a 3+ inch PVC pipe so paws can't reach it (Utah State IPM manual). Pick up pet food at night (CDC).
- CDC's "done" test: a week with no catches and no new droppings.
On baking soda: none of these guides recommends it, so there's no tested ratio to give.
Sources: ipm.ucanr.edu/home-and-landscape/house-mouse, cdc.gov/healthy-pets/rodent-control/trap-up.html, cdc.gov/healthy-pets/rodent-control/seal-up.html
